Mindy Roberts of The Mommy Blog asks the question Is it right to discipline someone else's kid?
When my kids have friends over, everyone needs to follow the house rules. I don't care if their parents let them hang off the ceiling fan, you just don't do it at my house.
I don't believe in spanking my kids or anyone else's child and I agree with Dana that I would hope no one would touch my children. I have told kids to stop running in my house and refrain from using inappropriate language but I have never had to time out someone else's kid.
My son has been disciplined at someone else's house and I think that is great, because it teaches him that there are rules wherever we go and we need to follow them no matter where we are.
There was an incident at the park where I only had Chicky and someone was trying to push her down a slide. To be quite honest I can't even remember who it was. All I saw through my mommy lens was a hand that was pushing my daughter. And unfortunately I automatically thought it was my son, but he was at camp. So I start yelling "no pushing, no pushing!". Once the situation was under control, I realized that Ducky wasn't even there and I just disciplined someone else's kid. I was a little embarrassed but it was better than my daughter getting another injury that week.
So is it OK to discipline another person's kid? Yes! When the situation calls for it, for their safety and protection of everyone playing.















2 witnessing the mayhem:
I agree with you that I enforce our house rules and would certainly stop anyone who was harming (or about to harm) my child. That said, we use time-outs and I don't think I'd put another kid in time-out - just let them know that what they did was wrong and if it was bad enough, mention to their parent.
Well there are many different types of disciple. I keep running into these situations alot with babysitters and my child. I don't mind if other people disciple my child but there is a line to it. Slapping, constant screaming, spraying them in the face with a waterbottle, and making them stand with their nose to the wall are some I don't really agree with. I think what you did yelling no pushing is completely acceptable. Especially when it involves the safety of small children.
Post a Comment